The gendered nose and its lack: 'medieval' nose-cutting and its modern manifestations.

Patricia Skinner

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Time magazine's cover photograph in August 2010 of a noseless Afghan woman beside the emotive strap line, "What happens if we leave Afghanistan," fuelled debate about the "medieval" practices of the Taliban, whose local commander had instructed her husband to take her nose and ears. Press reports attributed the violence to the Pashtun tradition that a dishonored husband "lost his nose." This equation of nose-cutting with tradition begs questions not only about the Orientalist lens of the western press when viewing Afghanistan, but also about the assumption that the word "medieval" can function as a label for such practices. A study of medieval nose-cutting suggests that its identification as an "eastern" practice should be challenged. Rather clearer is its connection with patriarchal values of authority and honor: the victims of such punishment have not always been women, but this is nevertheless a gendered punishment of the powerless by the powerful.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)45-67
JournalJournal of Women's History
Volume26
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2014

Keywords

  • mutilation
  • maiming
  • nose
  • violence against women
  • Islamic law
  • Afghanistan
  • history

Cite this

@article{685144c03b4b40d58f20b179b7096834,
title = "The gendered nose and its lack: 'medieval' nose-cutting and its modern manifestations.",
abstract = "Time magazine's cover photograph in August 2010 of a noseless Afghan woman beside the emotive strap line, {"}What happens if we leave Afghanistan,{"} fuelled debate about the {"}medieval{"} practices of the Taliban, whose local commander had instructed her husband to take her nose and ears. Press reports attributed the violence to the Pashtun tradition that a dishonored husband {"}lost his nose.{"} This equation of nose-cutting with tradition begs questions not only about the Orientalist lens of the western press when viewing Afghanistan, but also about the assumption that the word {"}medieval{"} can function as a label for such practices. A study of medieval nose-cutting suggests that its identification as an {"}eastern{"} practice should be challenged. Rather clearer is its connection with patriarchal values of authority and honor: the victims of such punishment have not always been women, but this is nevertheless a gendered punishment of the powerless by the powerful.",
keywords = "mutilation, maiming, nose, violence against women, Islamic law, Afghanistan, history",
author = "Patricia Skinner",
year = "2014",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "45--67",
number = "1",

}

The gendered nose and its lack : 'medieval' nose-cutting and its modern manifestations. / Skinner, Patricia.

Vol. 26, No. 1, 01.01.2014, p. 45-67.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The gendered nose and its lack

T2 - 'medieval' nose-cutting and its modern manifestations.

AU - Skinner, Patricia

PY - 2014/1/1

Y1 - 2014/1/1

N2 - Time magazine's cover photograph in August 2010 of a noseless Afghan woman beside the emotive strap line, "What happens if we leave Afghanistan," fuelled debate about the "medieval" practices of the Taliban, whose local commander had instructed her husband to take her nose and ears. Press reports attributed the violence to the Pashtun tradition that a dishonored husband "lost his nose." This equation of nose-cutting with tradition begs questions not only about the Orientalist lens of the western press when viewing Afghanistan, but also about the assumption that the word "medieval" can function as a label for such practices. A study of medieval nose-cutting suggests that its identification as an "eastern" practice should be challenged. Rather clearer is its connection with patriarchal values of authority and honor: the victims of such punishment have not always been women, but this is nevertheless a gendered punishment of the powerless by the powerful.

AB - Time magazine's cover photograph in August 2010 of a noseless Afghan woman beside the emotive strap line, "What happens if we leave Afghanistan," fuelled debate about the "medieval" practices of the Taliban, whose local commander had instructed her husband to take her nose and ears. Press reports attributed the violence to the Pashtun tradition that a dishonored husband "lost his nose." This equation of nose-cutting with tradition begs questions not only about the Orientalist lens of the western press when viewing Afghanistan, but also about the assumption that the word "medieval" can function as a label for such practices. A study of medieval nose-cutting suggests that its identification as an "eastern" practice should be challenged. Rather clearer is its connection with patriarchal values of authority and honor: the victims of such punishment have not always been women, but this is nevertheless a gendered punishment of the powerless by the powerful.

KW - mutilation

KW - maiming

KW - nose

KW - violence against women

KW - Islamic law

KW - Afghanistan

KW - history

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 45

EP - 67

IS - 1

ER -